HP Smart Tank 5101 vs 6001: Which Should You Choose? (November 2026)
Choose the HP Smart Tank 6001 for the stronger all-purpose choice, and choose the 5101 when its lower model tier fits your basic print, copy and scan needs. The biggest practical difference is the feature set and the ink system each printer uses.
On this page (12 sections)
- HP Smart Tank 5101 vs 6001: quick verdict
- How do the HP Smart Tank 5101 and 6001 compare?
- Which printer is better for everyday home printing?
- Which printer fits a home office better?
- Which printer is better for color printing?
- Which printer is better for black text?
- Which refill gives the safest brand match?
- What should you know about compatible ink?
- How should you choose ink for the 5101 or 6001?
- Who should buy the HP Smart Tank 5101?
- Who should buy the HP Smart Tank 6001?
- HP Smart Tank 5101 vs 6001: final choice
Choose the HP Smart Tank 6001 for the better all-purpose setup, and choose the HP Smart Tank 5101 when you only need basic home printing. In this hp smart tank 5101 vs 6001 comparison, the right pick depends on how often you print, whether you need regular color output and which refill system you plan to use.
Both printers belong to HP's Smart Tank family, so bottled ink is central to the buying decision. That makes refill compatibility more important than choosing by model number alone.
The 6001 is the overall winner for most readers because it suits a wider range of home and home-office printing needs. The 5101 remains the better fit for a simpler setup where you want the Smart Tank format without paying for features you won't use.
HP Smart Tank 5101 vs 6001: quick verdict
Pick the HP Smart Tank 6001 for frequent mixed printing, and pick the 5101 for straightforward home use. The 6001 earns the overall win because it is the more flexible choice for a household that prints documents, schoolwork, forms and color pages.
The 5101 makes sense when your printing is mostly routine documents and occasional color pages. It can also be a sensible choice when the printer's lower position in the range matches your budget and daily needs.
Ink cost is not decided by the printer name alone. A complete 31 and 32XL set can support either target model, while black-only users can choose a two-bottle 32XL refill instead.
The best first step is to decide whether you need a full color refill or mostly black ink. Then choose the printer whose features match your workload.
How do the HP Smart Tank 5101 and 6001 compare?
The HP Smart Tank 6001 is the stronger general-purpose choice, while the 5101 is better for basic printing routines. Their useful difference is not just the model number.
It is how much flexibility you want from the printer on your desk.
| Buying point | HP Smart Tank 5101 | HP Smart Tank 6001 |
|---|---|---|
| Best fit | Basic home printing | Mixed home and home-office printing |
| Ink system | Smart Tank bottled ink | Smart Tank bottled ink |
| Color refill choice | 31 and 32XL sets listed for the model | 31 and 32XL sets listed for the model |
| Black-only refill choice | Compatible 32XL bottles listed for the model | Compatible 32XL bottles listed for the model |
| Overall choice | Simpler needs | Broader everyday use |
This table focuses on the buying decision supported by the available product information. It does not treat the two models as identical, since the 6001 is the better pick when your printing needs extend beyond occasional documents.
For a closer look at another HP printer decision, see our comparison of HP OfficeJet Pro 8125 vs 9125.
Which printer is better for everyday home printing?
The HP Smart Tank 5101 suits a home that prints basic documents and occasional color pages. It is the more natural choice when your printer workload is steady but not demanding.
Think of school forms, household records, shipping pages and ordinary text documents. A tank printer fits this pattern because bottled ink is designed for repeated refills instead of frequent cartridge replacement.
The 5101 also works well for a household that wants one printer for printing, copying and scanning without making the printer the center of the home office. Its value comes from matching the workload without adding complexity you won't use.
Choose the 6001 instead if several people share the printer or if color pages appear often. A wider range of printing habits makes the 6001 easier to justify.
Which printer fits a home office better?
The HP Smart Tank 6001 is the better home-office pick. Shared printing rewards flexibility because one person may print text-heavy documents while another needs color pages, forms or school projects.
A home office also tends to create bursts of printing. Tax paperwork, invoices, shipping labels and project documents can arrive together, so a printer that fits more than one routine is the safer choice.
The 5101 can still suit a home office with a narrow, predictable workload. If you mainly print black text and only occasionally scan or copy, its simpler role may be enough.
Choose the 6001 when the printer will serve several users or when you expect your printing needs to grow. That decision is based on use, not on a claim that every household needs the higher model.
Which printer is better for color printing?
The HP Smart Tank 6001 is the better choice for regular color printing, but either printer needs the correct 31 and 32XL refill set. A complete color set includes black, cyan, magenta and yellow bottles.
The Topcolor 31 32XL Ink Bottle Set Compatible is listed for both the Smart Tank 5101 and 6001. It includes 1 black bottle and 3 color bottles, so it fits a household that prints both documents and color pages.
The inkgens 31 32XL Ink Bottle Set Refill also names both target printers. Its set includes a 165 ml black bottle, three 100 ml color bottles, gloves and bottle-cap opening tools.
A full color set is the better match for charts, school graphics, labels and family photos. If color printing is rare, black-only refills can keep your supply shelf simpler.
Which printer is better for black text?
Choose the HP Smart Tank 5101 for a basic black-text workload, and choose the 6001 when black printing is part of a broader shared workload. Text-heavy printing includes forms, drafts, instructions and office records.
Black ink is also the supply you may use fastest when most pages contain text. A two-bottle pack can be useful when you want a larger black-ink reserve without buying color bottles at the same time.
The Osinkjet 32XL Black Ink Bottle Compatible includes 2 black 32XL bottles and names both the Smart Tank 5101 and 6001 as compatible models. The bottles are 165 ml each, and the stated yield is 9000 pages per bottle.
The Osinkjet set is a black-only option, so it does not replace a complete color refill. Choose it when black pages dominate and you already have a plan for cyan, magenta and yellow ink.
Which refill gives the safest brand match?
Choose HP 32XL when genuine HP ink and a brand-matched refill matter most. HP describes this bottle as genuine black ink with a spill-free refill design and a stated yield of up to 6000 pages per bottle.
The compatibility information for HP 32XL names HP Smart Tank Plus 551, 651, 7001, 7301 and 7602 models. It does not name the Smart Tank 5101 or 6001 in the supplied compatibility list.
That makes HP 32XL a better fit for the compatible Smart Tank Plus printers named above than for the two printers in this comparison. The HP Smart Tank ink guide explains how the 31 and 32XL labels relate to HP tank-printer refills.
Use the exact printer and bottle pairing as your decision point. Genuine HP branding matters, but it does not override model compatibility.
What should you know about compatible ink?
Compatible ink gives you more refill choices for both the Smart Tank 5101 and 6001. The trade-off is that these bottles come from third-party brands rather than HP.
Topcolor offers a 4-pack with 1 black bottle and 3 color bottles. Its compatibility information specifically names the Smart Tank 5101 and 6001, along with several other Smart Tank models.
inkgens also offers a complete black and CMY set for both printers. Its bottles use an anti-leak, auto-stop design, and the package includes a pair of gloves and bottle-opening tools.
Osinkjet focuses on black ink with a 2-pack of 165 ml bottles. That makes it the most focused option here for a household that prints mostly text and wants black bottles in reserve.
Use compatible ink when the set names your printer and its bottle colors match the refill you need. Use HP 32XL when the target printer belongs to the HP Smart Tank Plus models named for that bottle.
How should you choose ink for the 5101 or 6001?
Choose a 4-bottle 31 and 32XL set if you print in color, and choose a black-only 32XL set if text makes up most of your pages. Your refill pattern should follow your actual page mix.
A complete set avoids running out of one color while the other bottles remain full. That matters if your household prints worksheets, charts, forms or images.
A black-only set makes more sense for letters, drafts, records and office documents. Osinkjet's 2-pack gives the 5101 and 6001 a focused black refill option, while Topcolor and inkgens cover black and color together.
For a broader cost comparison, read HP Instant Ink vs Smart Tank. That guide helps explain why a bottled-ink printer and a cartridge subscription suit different printing habits.
Who should buy the HP Smart Tank 5101?
Buy the HP Smart Tank 5101 when you want a simple tank printer for routine home documents and occasional color work. It is the better choice for a smaller, predictable workload.
Choose it for one or two users who print school forms, household paperwork, basic labels and everyday documents. Pair it with a complete color refill when your printing includes graphics, or a black-only pack when text dominates.
The 5101 is also a reasonable fit when you want to spend your attention on ink refills rather than on a broad home-office feature set. Its role is straightforward: handle common printing, copying and scanning tasks with bottled ink.
Choose the 6001 if the printer will serve several people or if you expect more varied printing. The higher model is easier to justify when the workload is shared.
Who should buy the HP Smart Tank 6001?
Buy the HP Smart Tank 6001 when you need the better all-purpose printer for a mixed household or home office. It is the overall winner in this comparison because it gives you more room to grow into different printing tasks.
Choose it for shared use, regular color documents and periods when several printing jobs arrive together. A complete Topcolor or inkgens refill set keeps black and color supplies together for either target printer.
The 6001 is also the better match when you want one printer to cover household paperwork and work-related pages. Its advantage is practical flexibility, not a promise that every page will cost less.
If you are still deciding between HP printer families, our HP Smart Tank 5101 review gives the 5101 a closer look. Use that review alongside this comparison when the 5101 is your current front-runner.
HP Smart Tank 5101 vs 6001: final choice
Choose the HP Smart Tank 6001 for most readers, especially shared homes and home offices. Pick the HP Smart Tank 5101 when your printing is basic, predictable and centered on routine documents.
For ink, choose Topcolor or inkgens when you need black and color bottles for either printer. Choose Osinkjet when black printing dominates and a 2-pack suits your refill pattern.
HP 32XL is the genuine HP option here, but its named compatibility list focuses on selected Smart Tank Plus models rather than the 5101 and 6001. The final hp smart tank 5101 vs 6001 decision is therefore simple: choose the 6001 for flexibility, or the 5101 for a more basic home printing role.
Frequently asked questions
Are HP Smart Tank 5101 and 6001 ink bottles the same?
The compatible refill sets in this comparison list both the HP Smart Tank 5101 and 6001. Ink compatibility depends on the bottle type and printer family, so the 31 and 32XL labels matter when choosing a refill.
Which HP Smart Tank printer is better for color documents?
The HP Smart Tank 6001 is the better overall choice when color documents are a regular part of your printing. Pair either printer with a complete black and CMY refill set rather than a black-only bottle.
Is HP 32XL genuine ink compatible with the Smart Tank 5101?
The HP 32XL data here identifies compatibility with selected HP Smart Tank Plus models, including the 551 and 651. The compatible sets in this post specifically name the Smart Tank 5101 and 6001.
Should you buy genuine HP ink or compatible ink?
Choose genuine HP ink when brand-matched supplies are your priority. Choose a compatible set when you need black and color bottles for the Smart Tank 5101 or 6001 and the refill set names your printer model.
Which printer should a home office choose?
Choose the HP Smart Tank 6001 for a home office that prints often and needs a broader all-purpose setup. Choose the 5101 for basic home printing when its simpler feature set covers your documents, copies and scans.
About this guide: Our look at HP Smart Tank 5101 vs 6001 printers draws on maker specs, materials and what owners report. See how we research.





